A Family-Owned Insurance Agency Serving Southern California Since 1998

Arlan Knutson Insurance Agency is a family-owned independent agency in Fallbrook that compares home, auto, business, and farm coverage from multiple carriers, so our clients get real options and a small team that knows them by name instead of a call center.

Family-owned since 1998

Independent agency working with 13 insurance carriers

Nationwide Elite Farm Certified Agency

Women-Owned & Operated. Real team members answer your calls.

How a Father-Daughter Agency Became a Southern California Fixture

Debb's dad started Arlan Knutson Insurance Agency in 1998. Two years later, Debb joined him, learning the business one client at a time. Today the agency is hers, and it still runs on the same idea he started with: get to know people, look at all their options, and be there when they call.


We've grown since then, but we've stayed small on purpose. Our team works out of our Fallbrook office, serving families, business owners, and farm owners from Orange County south through Riverside and San Diego Counties. Many of our clients have been with us for years, and some have been with us since the beginning.

Yellow gorse flowers in bloom against a blurred sky background.
New York City skyline on a sunny day, seen across blue water. One World Trade Center stands tall.

Our Mission

Our mission is to help Southern California families, business owners, and farm owners find coverage that fits their lives by comparing real options across multiple carriers, explaining them in plain English, and staying with our clients long after the policy is signed.

The Values Behind Every Policy We Write

Black arrow pointing to the right.
Options Over Sales Pitches

We'd rather show you a few real choices than push a single policy. Comparing carriers is the reason we're independent.

Black arrow pointing right.
Honest, Plain-English Advice

We tell you what a policy covers, what it doesn't, and when coverage is hard to find. We don't make promises we can't keep.

A black arrow pointing to the right.
Relationships That Last

We measure success by how long our clients stay with us, and many of them have been with us for years.

Black arrow pointing right.
Easy to Reach

Questions don't follow business plans. When you call, email, or stop by, you'll reach a person who can help.

Black arrow pointing right.
Showing Up for Our Community

We're part of the community we serve, and we give back through local events, volunteering, and sponsorships.

Why Clients Choose an Independent Family Agency


Independent by Design

We compare coverage across multiple carriers instead of selling one company's policies, so you see more than one option.


More Places to Look When Coverage Gets Hard

When a carrier pulls back from your area or won't renew your home, we have more places to look for coverage.


Real People Answer the Phone

Real team members answer our agency calls, so you can talk through your question with someone who can help.


A Team That Knows You

Our small team gets to know you and your policies, so you aren't starting from scratch every time you call.


Nationwide Elite Farm Certified

We're a Nationwide Elite Farm Certified Agency, helping farm owners cover their liability, buildings, and equipment.


Personal, Commercial, and Farm Under One Roof

We handle personal, commercial, and farm insurance at one agency, so your home, business, and farm coverage can all be reviewed together.

What Being Independent Means for You

A captive agent works for one insurance company and can only offer that company's policies. As an independent agency, we work with multiple carriers, which matters more than ever in California. Many carriers have stopped writing new home policies or are non-renewing homes in wildfire-exposed areas. Because we aren't tied to a single company, we have more places to look when coverage gets hard to find.



We can't promise every property can be placed or that the price will be what you hoped for. We can promise to look across the markets available to us and explain what we find in plain English.

Meet the Team Behind the Agency

Our team is small, and we like it that way. Whether you call, email, or stop by the Fallbrook office, you'll be working with people who know our clients and take the time to explain things.

Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Deb Bottomley

Owner
760-451-9835
Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Jennifer Bacalia

Office Manager and Agent
951-683-3730
Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Alyssa Casey

Office Manager and Agent
760-451-9835
Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Jenna Mangold

Administration and Customer Service
760-451-9835
Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Jessica Salyers

Customer Service
760-451-9835
Profile icon, grayscale illustration of a person's upper body against a white circle.

Katie Allen

Administration and CustomerService
951-683-3730

Insurance Carriers We Work With

Working with multiple carriers is what lets us compare options instead of handing you a single quote. These are the companies we currently write with:

  • Nationwide
  • American Modern
  • Stillwater Insurance Group
  • Travelers
  • AEGIS
  • Chubb Agribusiness
  • Chubb
  • American Collectors Insurance
  • Foremost Insurance Group
  • GeoVera
  • Progressive
  • Rain and Hail Insurance Service
  • United States Liability Insurance Group (USLI)

Our Insurance Partners

Nationwide insurance logo with a blue "N" shape and a white eagle; the word "Nationwide" below.
The mutual of omaha logo has a lion on it.
CHUBB logo: Black text on white background.
The logo for united healthcare is blue and white.
Stillwater Insurance Group logo in blue and gray with wave icon
National General Insurance logo with orange and blue text and arrow.

Customer Testimonials on Google

Mary B.

Christa H.

Stephen B.

Morning F.

Showing Up for the Fallbrook Community

Fallbrook is our home base, and we try to give back to the community that has supported us. Our team takes part in Fallbrook Chamber events and volunteers with the Chamber throughout the year. The agency also sponsors a local charity golf tournament.

Black outline of California state shape on a white background

Serving Families and Businesses Across Southern California

From our Fallbrook office, we work with clients in Temecula, Murrieta, Escondido, Ramona, and Borrego Springs, along with communities from Orange County to the Mexican border. We've served clients in Moreno Valley for many years and still do, and we work with clients in Irvine and throughout Orange County by phone, email, and online.

Questions About Our Agency

  • Who owns Arlan Knutson Insurance Agency?

    Debb Bottomley owns the agency. Her dad started it in 1998, and Debb joined him in 2000. It has been family-owned the entire time.

  • Is Arlan Knutson Insurance an independent agency?

    Yes. We're an independent insurance agency, which means we work with multiple carriers rather than just one. That lets us compare coverage and pricing across companies for our clients.

  • Which insurance companies does Arlan Knutson Insurance work with?

    We currently work with 13 carriers, including Nationwide, Travelers, Chubb, Progressive, Stillwater, American Modern, Foremost, GeoVera, and United States Liability Insurance Group (USLI). The full list is on this page.

  • Where is your office?

    Our only office is at 425 East Alvarado Street, Suite H, Fallbrook, CA 92028. Clients across Southern California work with us by phone, email, and online, and anyone is welcome to visit in person.

Prefer to speak directly?

Whether you're protecting a home, a business, or a farm, we'll compare your options across multiple carriers and explain what we find. Fill out the form below, call 760-451-9835, or email csr@arlanknutsoninsurance.com.

Let's Get to Know Each Other

Whether you need coverage for your home, your business, or your farm, we'd like to hear what you're looking for and show you your options. Fill out the form below, call 760-451-9835, or email csr@arlanknutsoninsurance.com.